"You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view... Until you climb inside of his skin and walk around in it."
Monday, 16 June 2008
TKAM - Chapter 5
Miss Maudie says, "... sometimes the Bible in the hand of one man is worse than a whiskey bottle in the hand of (someone else)." Try to explain her meaning to a classmate who doesn't understand.
14 comments:
Anonymous
said...
mmm i really don't know, from what I understood is that a men with a Bible can be dangerous because he can explain religion from his point of view or say things that are wrong and make other people to thing like him. Well i'm not sure teacher if it is right or wrong =S we'll disscus this in class. see youu theree :)
I dont know who Miss Mauddie is, so I really cant say which is her point of view or the context in which teh statmente is said. The bible gives you knowledge and belief, so you are lightened, while the whiskey can take you to any part, and having no problems, I really dont understand much
I think that the Bible gives people some keys for their life and is their responsability to use them in a wrong or a right way. Maybe the man takes advantage of them to do something wrong "because the Bible says that is not a sin" but he didn't find the real meaning.
Well i think that the bible represents knowladge, so if a man have it, it have power and sometimes he can use it wrong, and a bottle of whishky it is only something that pass and there it finish, a bottle of whisky is nothing.
The wrong interpretation of the bible can produce disasters (as current religions), and that wrong message of a wrong interpretation reachs other people.
A bottle of whiskey in the hand of one man can be treated.
i agree with the other classmates, i think whisky is better than a bible :p jeje, a man with a bible can say whatever he imagine reading it, so about all this we can say, viva el whisky! xD
the bible is kind of "subjetive", so the man who is interpreting it is in someway winning knowledge and gives him the oportunitie to use it in real life, even if it is for good or bad. But a bottle of whiskey does not takes the same importance as the bible and no one gives serious attention to the efects that causes.
How nice to have Nancy as an international member of the blog! I think if Nancy explained about the Jim Crow laws and all the black/white situation in America at the time of TKAM it would be a great idea and would give our students a lot of very useful background knowlegde.
Kids, as regards the quote: do you think a bottle of whisky in the hands of Atticus, for example, would be a dangerous thing? Why? And how about the Bible in the hands of someone who interprets it his own way and takes the Bible literally? Could that be dangerous? Why? I think Tatu pretty much hit the nail on the head in that sense.
well i totally agree with tatu =) anyone who understand or take literatly what the bible says can be really dangerous as many others will probably follow or trust her/him. that can be really complicated. and a man with a bottle of wisky may be it´s not as dangerous as what i mention before
if you are guide by the bible literaly things can turn wrong, for ejeample the saudis who think that they have to kill the people that dont believe in Ala tito
"The wrong interpretation of the bible can produce disasters (as current religions), and that wrong message of a wrong interpretation reachs other people.
A bottle of whiskey in the hand of one man can be treated."BY TATU
I think the same as tatu .. becose i cant imagine enything else
Viole, Tito, Esteban and Martín reading and reading...
Cande, Tatu y Manu love TKAM!
Students enjoying their literature class
Our first novel: ANIMAL FARM
"All animals are equal but some animals are more equal than others."
"THREE LEGS OK"
"DON'T WORRY LADS, WE'RE READY FOR THEM."
ESCUELA DE LOS PADRES - 4TH Year Literature 2008
Welcome to our blog! Here we will keep in touch during the whole school year and share our activities.
Instructions: For each reading assignment I would like you to post something to this blog about the reading. Among the things you may want to comment on are:
1- Things that have happened in the story at this point and their significance to the overall story.
2- Characters (their actions, motivations,what they say, how they affect other characters, etc.)
3- Quotes from the reading, especially if they are significant in developing the many themes in the novel.
4- Questions that you have about what you've read (including things you don't understand)
Make sure that you put your name at the beginning of each entry you make so that we know who you are as we read the blog.I hope to make this blog a major part of our class discussion over the daily reading, but how effective that is depends entirely on what you contribute. Remember, you need to post something for each reading assignment, and it must be posted before you come to class. I will leave the length up to you, but what you write should be long enough to meaningfully contribute to our discussion. I will discuss with you a fair way to give credit for these blog postings.
A quote or two
What is important is to keep learning, to enjoy challenge, and to tolerate ambiguity. In the end there are no certain answers. Martina Homer
Gabriela N. Duaigües. Profesora Superior de inglés. Licenciada en Lengua Inglesa. Diplomada en Gestión Educativa. Especialista en Educación y Nuevas tecnologías.
14 comments:
mmm i really don't know, from what I understood is that a men with a Bible can be dangerous because he can explain religion from his point of view or say things that are wrong and make other people to thing like him. Well i'm not sure teacher if it is right or wrong =S we'll disscus this in class.
see youu theree
:)
...and make other people THINK..
i confused !
I dont know who Miss Mauddie is, so I really cant say which is her point of view or the context in which teh statmente is said. The bible gives you knowledge and belief, so you are lightened, while the whiskey can take you to any part, and having no problems, I really dont understand much
I think that the Bible gives people some keys for their life and is their responsability to use them in a wrong or a right way. Maybe the man takes advantage of them to do something wrong "because the Bible says that is not a sin" but he didn't find the real meaning.
Well i think that the bible represents knowladge, so if a man have it, it have power and sometimes he can use it wrong, and a bottle of whishky it is only something that pass and there it finish, a bottle of whisky is nothing.
The wrong interpretation of the bible can produce disasters (as current religions), and that wrong message of a wrong interpretation reachs other people.
A bottle of whiskey in the hand of one man can be treated.
i agree with the other classmates, i think whisky is better than a bible :p jeje, a man with a bible can say whatever he imagine reading it, so about all this we can say, viva el whisky! xD
c u in class
the bible is kind of "subjetive", so the man who is interpreting it is in someway winning knowledge and gives him the oportunitie to use it in real life, even if it is for good or bad.
But a bottle of whiskey does not takes the same importance as the bible and no one gives serious attention to the efects that causes.
Dear Students,
I've looked at your blog and your comments. You seem to understand the quotes very well.
Do you know what Jim Crow laws are?
Nancy
How nice to have Nancy as an international member of the blog! I think if Nancy explained about the Jim Crow laws and all the black/white situation in America at the time of TKAM it would be a great idea and would give our students a lot of very useful background knowlegde.
Kids, as regards the quote: do you think a bottle of whisky in the hands of Atticus, for example, would be a dangerous thing? Why?
And how about the Bible in the hands of someone who interprets it his own way and takes the Bible literally? Could that be dangerous? Why? I think Tatu pretty much hit the nail on the head in that sense.
well i totally agree with tatu =)
anyone who understand or take literatly what the bible says can be really dangerous as many others will probably follow or trust her/him. that can be really complicated. and a man with a bottle of wisky may be it´s not as dangerous as what i mention before
if you are guide by the bible literaly things can turn wrong, for ejeample the saudis who think that they have to kill the people that dont believe in Ala
tito
"The wrong interpretation of the bible can produce disasters (as current religions), and that wrong message of a wrong interpretation reachs other people.
A bottle of whiskey in the hand of one man can be treated."BY TATU
I think the same as tatu .. becose i cant imagine enything else
cya
Esteban
YelicAntony
do not trust anyone
Post a Comment